| Three-time NAIA Wrestling All-Americans | ||||||
| Data updated after the 2013 NAIA Wrestling Championships | ||||||
| Data compiled by Dan Cosimi of The Ohio Wrestling Network | ||||||
| Total: 16 Three-time All-Americans, 52 All-America honors | ||||||
| Active: 0 | ||||||
| First | Last | Year | Place | Weight | College | High School |
| Spencer | Adams | 2012 | Sixth place | 197 pounds | Campbellsville University | Pleasant High School |
| Spencer | Adams | 2011 | Seventh place | 197 pounds | Campbellsville University | Pleasant High School |
| Spencer | Adams | 2009 | Sixth place | 184 pounds | Campbellsville University | Pleasant High School |
| Quantres | Bates | 1999 | Champion | 133 pounds | University of Findlay | Chillicothe High School |
| Quantres | Bates | 1998 | Champion | 118 pounds | University of Findlay | Chillicothe High School |
| Quantres | Bates | 1997 | Fifth place | 118 pounds | University of Findlay | Chillicothe High School |
| Dustin | Center | 2010 | Sixth place | 157 pounds | University of the Cumberlands | William Mason High School |
| Dustin | Center | 2008 | Fourth place | 149 pounds | University of the Cumberlands | William Mason High School |
| Dustin | Center | 2007 | Sixth place | 149 pounds | University of the Cumberlands | William Mason High School |
| Dustin | Center | 2006 | Eighth place | 149 pounds | University of the Cumberlands | William Mason High School |
| David | Clemens | 2011 | Eighth place | 165 pounds | Campbellsville University | Beavercreek High School |
| David | Clemens | 2008 | Fifth place | 157 pounds | Campbellsville University | Beavercreek High School |
| David | Clemens | 2007 | Second place | 157 pounds | Campbellsville University | Beavercreek High School |
| David | Clemens | 2006 | Seventh place | 157 pounds | Campbellsville University | Beavercreek High School |
| Zach | Flake | 2009 | Second place | 141 pounds | Campbellsville University | Lakota West High School |
| Zach | Flake | 2008 | Sixth place | 141 pounds | Campbellsville University | Lakota West High School |
| Zach | Flake | 2007 | Champion | 141 pounds | Campbellsville University | Lakota West High School |
| Ray | Hegarty | 1995 | Fifth place | 118 pounds | University of Findlay | Highland High School (Medina County) |
| Ray | Hegarty | 1994 | Fourth place | 118 pounds | University of Findlay | Highland High School (Medina County) |
| Ray | Hegarty | 1993 | Fourth place | 118 pounds | University of Findlay | Highland High School (Medina County) |
| Jim | Joaquin | 2000 | Fifth place | 285 pounds | University of Findlay | N/A High School (Southgate, Michigan) |
| Jim | Joaquin | 1999 | Fifth place | 275 pounds | University of Findlay | N/A High School (Southgate, Michigan) |
| Jim | Joaquin | 1998 | Fifth place | 275 pounds | University of Findlay | N/A High School (Southgate, Michigan) |
| Adam | Koballa | 2010 | Sixth place | 141 pounds | Notre Dame College | Saint Peter L. M. Chanel High School |
| Adam | Koballa | 2009 | Champion | 141 pounds | Notre Dame College | Saint Peter L. M. Chanel High School |
| Adam | Koballa | 2008 | Second place | 141 pounds | Notre Dame College | Saint Peter L. M. Chanel High School |
| Ron | Lucy | 1995 | Second place | 158 pounds | University of Findlay | Galion High School |
| Ron | Lucy | 1994 | Third place | 158 pounds | University of Findlay | Galion High School |
| Ron | Lucy | 1993 | Fifth place | 158 pounds | University of Findlay | Galion High School |
| Ron | Lucy | 1992 | Sixth place | 158 pounds | University of Findlay | Galion High School |
| Floyd | Marshall | 1966 | Second place | 157 pounds | University of Findlay | N/A High School (N/A) |
| Floyd | Marshall | 1965 | Second place | 157 pounds | University of Findlay | N/A High School (N/A) |
| Floyd | Marshall | 1964 | Champion | 157 pounds | University of Findlay | N/A High School (N/A) |
| Roger | Miller | 2005 | Champion | 285 pounds | Lindenwood University | Chaminade-Julienne High School |
| Roger | Miller | 2004 | Third place | 285 pounds | Lindenwood University | Chaminade-Julienne High School |
| Roger | Miller | 2003 | Second place | 285 pounds | Lindenwood University | Chaminade-Julienne High School |
| Roger | Miller | 2002 | Fifth place | 285 pounds | Lindenwood University | Chaminade-Julienne High School |
| Jeffrey | Pelton | 2011 | Third place | 149 pounds | Notre Dame College | Bellevue High School |
| Jeffrey | Pelton | 2010 | Champion | 149 pounds | Notre Dame College | Bellevue High School |
| Jeffrey | Pelton | 2009 | Third place | 149 pounds | Notre Dame College | Bellevue High School |
| Tommy | Pretty | 2011 | Third place | 141 pounds | Campbellsville University | Archbishop William H. Elder High School |
| Tommy | Pretty | 2010 | Champion | 133 pounds | Campbellsville University | Archbishop William H. Elder High School |
| Tommy | Pretty | 2009 | Eighth place | 133 pounds | Campbellsville University | Archbishop William H. Elder High School |
| Thomas | Straughn | 2011 | Second place | 157 pounds | Notre Dame College | Perry High School (Stark County) |
| Thomas | Straughn | 2010 | Champion | 157 pounds | Notre Dame College | Perry High School (Stark County) |
| Thomas | Straughn | 2009 | Fourth place | 157 pounds | Notre Dame College | Perry High School (Stark County) |
| Bubba | Taylor | 1997 | Champion | 150 pounds | University of Findlay | Clyde High School |
| Bubba | Taylor | 1996 | Champion | 150 pounds | University of Findlay | Clyde High School |
| Bubba | Taylor | 1995 | Champion | 142 pounds | University of Findlay | Clyde High School |
| Dave | Weilbacher | 1995 | Fourth place | 134 pounds | University of Findlay | Memorial High School (Auglaize County) |
| Dave | Weilbacher | 1991 | Second place | 126 pounds | University of Findlay | Memorial High School (Auglaize County) |
| Dave | Weilbacher | 1990 | Eighth place | 126 pounds | University of Findlay | Memorial High School (Auglaize County) |