| Four-time NCAA Division 1 Wrestling All-Americans | ||||||
| Data updated after the 2012 NCAA Division 1 Wrestling Championships | ||||||
| Data compiled by Dan Cosimi of The Ohio Wrestling Network | ||||||
| Total: 12 Four-time All-Americans, 48 All-America honors | ||||||
| First | Last | Year | Place | Weight | College | High School |
| Ryan | Bertin | 2005 | Champion | 157 pounds | University of Michigan | Saint Edward High School |
| Ryan | Bertin | 2004 | Third place | 157 pounds | University of Michigan | Saint Edward High School |
| Ryan | Bertin | 2003 | Champion | 157 pounds | University of Michigan | Saint Edward High School |
| Ryan | Bertin | 2002 | Sixth place | 157 pounds | University of Michigan | Saint Edward High School |
| Mike | DeAnna | 1981 | Second place | 167 pounds | University of Iowa | Bay High School |
| Mike | DeAnna | 1979 | Second place | 167 pounds | University of Iowa | Bay High School |
| Mike | DeAnna | 1978 | Sixth place | 167 pounds | University of Iowa | Bay High School |
| Mike | DeAnna | 1977 | Third place | 167 pounds | University of Iowa | Bay High School |
| Gregg | Elinsky | 1987 | Third place | 167 pounds | Pennsylvania State University | Saint Edward High School |
| Gregg | Elinsky | 1986 | Second place | 158 pounds | Pennsylvania State University | Saint Edward High School |
| Gregg | Elinsky | 1985 | Second place | 158 pounds | Pennsylvania State University | Saint Edward High School |
| Gregg | Elinsky | 1984 | Seventh place | 158 pounds | Pennsylvania State University | Saint Edward High School |
| Jim | Heffernan | 1987 | Second place | 150 pounds | University of Iowa | Saint Edward High School |
| Jim | Heffernan | 1986 | Champion | 150 pounds | University of Iowa | Saint Edward High School |
| Jim | Heffernan | 1985 | Second place | 150 pounds | University of Iowa | Saint Edward High School |
| Jim | Heffernan | 1983 | Fourth place | 150 pounds | University of Iowa | Saint Edward High School |
| Joe | Heskett | 2002 | Champion | 165 pounds | Iowa State University | Walsh Jesuit High School |
| Joe | Heskett | 2001 | Second place | 165 pounds | Iowa State University | Walsh Jesuit High School |
| Joe | Heskett | 2000 | Second place | 165 pounds | Iowa State University | Walsh Jesuit High School |
| Joe | Heskett | 1999 | Third place | 165 pounds | Iowa State University | Walsh Jesuit High School |
| Lee | Kemp | 1978 | Champion | 158 pounds | University of Wisconsin | Chardon High School |
| Lee | Kemp | 1977 | Champion | 158 pounds | University of Wisconsin | Chardon High School |
| Lee | Kemp | 1976 | Champion | 158 pounds | University of Wisconsin | Chardon High School |
| Lee | Kemp | 1975 | Second place | 150 pounds | University of Wisconsin | Chardon High School |
| Joe | McFarland | 1985 | Second place | 126 pounds | University of Michigan | North Olmsted High School |
| Joe | McFarland | 1984 | Second place | 126 pounds | University of Michigan | North Olmsted High School |
| Joe | McFarland | 1982 | Sixth place | 118 pounds | University of Michigan | North Olmsted High School |
| Joe | McFarland | 1981 | Fifth place | 118 pounds | University of Michigan | North Olmsted High School |
| Pat | Milkovich | 1976 | Second place | 134 pounds | Michigan State University | Maple Heights High School |
| Pat | Milkovich | 1975 | Second place | 126 pounds | Michigan State University | Maple Heights High School |
| Pat | Milkovich | 1974 | Champion | 126 pounds | Michigan State University | Maple Heights High School |
| Pat | Milkovich | 1972 | Champion | 126 pounds | Michigan State University | Maple Heights High School |
| Markus | Mollica | 1996 | Fourth place | 167 pounds | Arizona State University | Walsh Jesuit High School |
| Markus | Mollica | 1995 | Champion | 167 pounds | Arizona State University | Walsh Jesuit High School |
| Markus | Mollica | 1994 | Fifth place | 158 pounds | Arizona State University | Walsh Jesuit High School |
| Markus | Mollica | 1993 | Champion | 158 pounds | Arizona State University | Walsh Jesuit High School |
| Lance | Palmer | 2010 | Second place | 149 pounds | The Ohio State University | Saint Edward High School |
| Lance | Palmer | 2009 | Fourth place | 149 pounds | The Ohio State University | Saint Edward High School |
| Lance | Palmer | 2008 | Eighth place | 149 pounds | The Ohio State University | Saint Edward High School |
| Lance | Palmer | 2007 | Fourth place | 149 pounds | The Ohio State University | Saint Edward High School |
| Jake | Percival | 2005 | Third place | 157 pounds | Ohio University | Marion L. Steele High School |
| Jake | Percival | 2004 | Second place | 157 pounds | Ohio University | Marion L. Steele High School |
| Jake | Percival | 2003 | Fifth place | 149 pounds | Ohio University | Marion L. Steele High School |
| Jake | Percival | 2002 | Fourth place | 149 pounds | Ohio University | Marion L. Steele High School |
| Tommy | Rowlands | 2004 | Champion | 285 pounds | The Ohio State University | Bishop Michael J. Ready High School |
| Tommy | Rowlands | 2003 | Sixth place | 285 pounds | The Ohio State University | Bishop Michael J. Ready High School |
| Tommy | Rowlands | 2002 | Champion | 285 pounds | The Ohio State University | Bishop Michael J. Ready High School |
| Tommy | Rowlands | 2001 | Second place | 285 pounds | The Ohio State University | Bishop Michael J. Ready High School |