| NCAA Division 3 Wrestling All-Americans | ||||||
| Data updated after the 2013 NCAA Division 3 Wrestling Championships | ||||||
| Data compiled by Dan Cosimi of The Ohio Wrestling Network | ||||||
| Total: 199 All-Americans, 301 All-America honors | ||||||
| Active: 0 | ||||||
| First | Last | Year | Place | Weight | College | High School |
| Kyle | Kwiat | 2013 | Champion | 174 pounds | Ohio Northern University | Cecilius Calvert High School |
| Andy | Lovins | 2013 | Fifth place | 197 pounds | Heidelberg University | Lake Shore High School (Stevensville, Michigan) |
| Kyle | Kwiat | 2012 | Champion | 174 pounds | Ohio Northern University | Cecilius Calvert High School |
| Derick | Hesson | 2012 | Third place | 285 pounds | University of Mount Union | Caldwell High School |
| James | Myers | 2012 | Sixth place | 165 pounds | Olivet College | Indian Creek High School |
| Josh | Malave | 2012 | Seventh place | 141 pounds | University of Mount Union | Lutheran West High School |
| Isaac | Dukes | 2012 | Seventh place | 157 pounds | Case Western Reserve University | Ravenna High School |
| Jefferson | Ajayi | 2012 | Seventh place | 184 pounds | Wesleyan College | Shaker Heights High School |
| Greg | Rhoads | 2012 | Eighth place | 184 pounds | Wabash College | Hillsboro High School |
| Isaac | Dukes | 2011 | Third place | 149 pounds | Case Western Reserve University | Ravenna High School |
| Luke | Miller | 2011 | Third place | 165 pounds | Ohio Northern University | Indiana High School (Indiana, Pennsylvania) |
| Bill | Schindel | 2011 | Third place | 197 pounds | University of Mount Union | Archbishop Edward F. Hoban High School |
| Kyle | Kwiat | 2011 | Fifth place | 174 pounds | Ohio Northern University | Cecilius Calvert High School |
| Derick | Hesson | 2011 | Fifth place | 285 pounds | University of Mount Union | Caldwell High School |
| Riki | Reynolds | 2011 | Sixth place | 125 pounds | University of Mount Union | Pleasant High School |
| Greg | Rhoads | 2011 | Eighth place | 184 pounds | Wabash College | Hillsboro High School |
| Isaac | Dukes | 2010 | Champion | 149 pounds | Case Western Reserve University | Ravenna High School |
| Luke | Miller | 2010 | Champion | 157 pounds | Ohio Northern University | Indiana High School (Indiana, Pennsylvania) |
| Zach | Mizer | 2010 | Second place | 157 pounds | Heidelberg University | Perry High School (Stark County) |
| Kyle | Kwiat | 2010 | Fourth place | 174 pounds | Ohio Northern University | Cecilius Calvert High School |
| Bill | Schindel | 2010 | Seventh place | 197 pounds | Mount Union College | Archbishop Edward F. Hoban High School |
| Ben | Adams | 2010 | Eighth place | 184 pounds | John Carroll University | Winston Churchill High School (Livonia, Michigan) |
| Luke | Miller | 2009 | Fourth place | 157 pounds | Ohio Northern University | Indiana High School (Indiana, Pennsylvania) |
| Andrew | Gardella | 2009 | Sixth place | 149 pounds | Case Western Reserve University | Saint Peter L. M. Chanel High School |
| Bill | Schindel | 2009 | Eighth place | 197 pounds | Mount Union College | Archbishop Edward F. Hoban High School |
| Elliott | Spence | 2008 | Second place | 149 pounds | College of Mount Saint Joseph | Archbishop William H. Elder High School |
| Gino | Russo | 2008 | Sixth place | 165 pounds | Baldwin-Wallace College | Nordonia High School |
| Ryan | Bowers | 2008 | Sixth place | 285 pounds | Heidelberg University | Elida High School |
| Ryan | Fogliano | 2008 | Seventh place | 197 pounds | Heidelberg University | Maple Heights High School |
| David | Manoogian | 2008 | Eighth place | 141 pounds | Case Western Reserve University | Green High School |
| Jason | Roush | 2007 | Second place | 149 pounds | College of Mount Saint Joseph | Van Wert High School |
| Bryan | Kmetz | 2007 | Second place | 285 pounds | Baldwin-Wallace College | Brunswick High School |
| Joe | Pflug | 2007 | Third place | 149 pounds | Heidelberg University | Maple Heights High School |
| Gino | Russo | 2007 | Sixth place | 165 pounds | Baldwin-Wallace College | Nordonia High School |
| Elliott | Spence | 2007 | Eighth place | 157 pounds | College of Mount Saint Joseph | Archbishop William H. Elder High School |
| Ryan | Summers | 2007 | Eighth place | 184 pounds | John Carroll University | Plainwell High School (Plainwell, Michigan) |
| Joe | Pflug | 2006 | Champion | 157 pounds | Heidelberg University | Maple Heights High School |
| Ty | Klofta | 2006 | Second place | 125 pounds | Ohio Northern University | Indian Lake High School |
| Jason | Roush | 2006 | Third place | 149 pounds | College of Mount Saint Joseph | Van Wert High School |
| Carl | Amerine | 2006 | Sixth place | 149 pounds | Wilmington College | Franklin Heights High School |
| Tim | Maxworthy | 2006 | Sixth place | 165 pounds | Heidelberg University | Buckeye High School (Medina County) |
| Sean | Connelly | 2006 | Seventh place | 149 pounds | Mount Union College | Lake Catholic High School |
| Elliott | Spence | 2006 | Eighth place | 157 pounds | College of Mount Saint Joseph | Archbishop William H. Elder High School |
| Ryan | Summers | 2005 | Second place | 184 pounds | John Carroll University | Plainwell High School (Plainwell, Michigan) |
| Jason | Roush | 2005 | Third place | 149 pounds | College of Mount Saint Joseph | Van Wert High School |
| Tim | Ruberg | 2005 | Third place | 174 pounds | Johnson and Wales University | William H. Harrison High School |
| Ty | Klofta | 2005 | Eighth place | 125 pounds | Ohio Northern University | Indian Lake High School |
| Mike | Kemble | 2005 | Eighth place | 149 pounds | Thiel College | Southeast High School (Portage County) |
| Carl | Amerine | 2005 | Eighth place | 157 pounds | Wilmington College | Franklin Heights High School |
| Devin | Carman | 2005 | Eighth place | 197 pounds | Baldwin-Wallace College | Geneva High School |
| Mark | Hawald II | 2004 | Third place | 174 pounds | John Carroll University | Solon High School |
| Derek | Ankney | 2004 | Fifth place | 285 pounds | John Carroll University | Sidney High School |
| Zak | Kallai | 2004 | Eighth place | 149 pounds | Case Western Reserve University | Wadsworth High School |
| Jared | Selover | 2003 | Fourth place | 125 pounds | Baldwin-Wallace College | Wapakoneta High School |
| Artie | Mauser | 2003 | Sixth place | 184 pounds | John Carroll University | Aurora High School |
| Andrew | Vogel | 2003 | Seventh place | 149 pounds | Messiah College | Cuyahoga Valley Christian Academy |
| Zak | Kallai | 2003 | Eighth place | 149 pounds | Case Western Reserve University | Wadsworth High School |
| Jimmy | Wallace | 2002 | Champion | 157 pounds | Wilmington College | Valley View High School |
| Eric | Urdzik | 2002 | Second place | 285 pounds | John Carroll University | Brecksville-Broadview Heights High School |
| Zak | Kallai | 2002 | Fifth place | 149 pounds | Case Western Reserve University | Wadsworth High School |
| Jared | Combs | 2002 | Fifth place | 184 pounds | College of Mount Saint Joseph | N/A High School (Scott, Kentucky) |
| Andrew | Vogel | 2002 | Seventh place | 149 pounds | Messiah College | Cuyahoga Valley Christian Academy |
| Chris | Nader | 2002 | Eighth place | 165 pounds | Case Western Reserve University | Saint Ignatius High School |
| Andrew | Vogel | 2001 | Second place | 149 pounds | Messiah College | Cuyahoga Valley Christian Academy |
| Jimmy | Wallace | 2001 | Third place | 157 pounds | Wilmington College | Valley View High School |
| Mike | Markovic | 2001 | Fourth place | 149 pounds | John Carroll University | Brecksville-Broadview Heights High School |
| Danny | Anderson | 2001 | Fifth place | 165 pounds | Mount Union College | Chardon High School |
| Jarrod | Martin | 2001 | Fifth place | 197 pounds | College of Mount Saint Joseph | Beavercreek High School |
| Eric | Urdzik | 2001 | Fifth place | 285 pounds | John Carroll University | Brecksville-Broadview Heights High School |
| Zak | Kallai | 2001 | Sixth place | 149 pounds | Case Western Reserve University | Wadsworth High School |
| Chris | Nader | 2001 | Sixth place | 157 pounds | Case Western Reserve University | Saint Ignatius High School |
| Wade | Chapman | 2001 | Seventh place | 197 pounds | Muskingum University | Highland High School (Medina County) |
| Jimmy | Wallace | 2000 | Fifth place | 149 pounds | Wilmington College | Valley View High School |
| Danny | Anderson | 2000 | Sixth place | 165 pounds | Mount Union College | Chardon High School |
| Paul | Grigsby | 2000 | Seventh place | 197 pounds | Ohio Northern University | Tecumseh High School |
| Eric | Urdzik | 2000 | Seventh place | 285 pounds | John Carroll University | Brecksville-Broadview Heights High School |
| Kevin | Atkins | 2000 | Eighth place | 174 pounds | Baldwin-Wallace College | Olmsted Falls High School |
| Matt | Hammill | 1999 | Champion | 197 pounds | Rochester Institute of Technology | Loveland High School |
| Rich | Eslich | 1999 | Champion | 285 pounds | John Carroll University | Louisville High School |
| Jimmy | Wandsnider | 1999 | Third place | 157 pounds | College of Mount Saint Joseph | William H. Harrison High School |
| Bryan | Ray | 1999 | Third place | 174 pounds | Wilmington College | N/A High School (N/A) |
| Jim | Ayers | 1999 | Third place | 184 pounds | John Carroll University | Lake Catholic High School |
| Jimmy | Wallce | 1999 | Fifth place | 149 pounds | Wilmington College | Valley View High School |
| Ryan | Collins | 1999 | Fifth place | 285 pounds | Capital University | Paulding High School |
| Brandon | Newill | 1999 | Seventh place | 125 pounds | Capital University | N/A High School (Mount Pleasant, Pennsylvania) |
| Justin | Kerr | 1999 | Eighth place | 197 pounds | John Carroll University | Mapleton High School |
| Matt | Hamill | 1998 | Champion | 190 pounds | Rochester Institute of Technology | Loveland High School |
| Jerry | Grammes | 1998 | Second place | 142 pounds | Wilmington College | Strongsville High School |
| Joe | Maiani | 1998 | Second place | 150 pounds | Ohio Northern University | Saint Mary Central Catholic High School |
| Nate | Samblanet | 1998 | Third place | 150 pounds | John Carroll University | Vermilion High School |
| Justin | Kerr | 1998 | Third place | 167 pounds | John Carroll University | Mapleton High School |
| Rich | Eslich | 1998 | Fourth place | 275 pounds | John Carroll University | Louisville High School |
| Ben | Hahlen | 1998 | Seventh place | 134 pounds | John Carroll University | Jackson-Milton High School |
| Jim | Ayers | 1998 | Eighth place | 177 pounds | John Carroll University | Lake Catholic High School |
| Matt | Hamill | 1997 | Champion | 167 pounds | Rochester Institute of Technology | Loveland High School |
| Jerry | Grammes | 1997 | Third place | 142 pounds | Wilmington College | Strongsville High School |
| Dan | Ambroziak | 1997 | Fifth place | 142 pounds | Mount Union College | Lake Catholic High School |
| Jason | Kessen | 1997 | Fifth place | 158 pounds | John Carroll University | Central Catholic High School (Allen County) |
| Matt | Colucci | 1997 | Sixth place | 126 pounds | John Carroll University | North High School (Delaware County) |
| Joe | Maiani | 1997 | Sixth place | 150 pounds | Ohio Northern University | Saint Mary Central Catholic High School |
| Justin | Kerr | 1997 | Sixth place | 167 pounds | John Carroll University | Mapleton High School |
| Ryan | Muzykoski | 1997 | Seventh place | 134 pounds | Heidelberg University | Licking Valley High School |
| Jason | Miller | 1997 | Seventh place | 158 pounds | Heidelberg University | Hopewell-Loudon High School |
| Derek | Messmer | 1996 | Champion | 275 pounds | Case Western Reserve University | Rossford High School |
| Brian | Malloy | 1996 | Fifth place | 150 pounds | Mount Union College | Lake Catholic High School |
| Jason | Miller | 1996 | Sixth place | 158 pounds | Heidelberg University | Hopewell-Loudon High School |
| Joe | Maiani | 1996 | Eighth place | 142 pounds | Ohio Northern University | Saint Mary Central Catholic High School |
| Jason | Weigand | 1996 | Eighth place | 275 pounds | Mount Union College | West Holmes High School |
| Chris | Ricklic | 1995 | Champion | 167 pounds | Case Western Reserve University | New Philadelphia High School |
| J.J. | Huszczo | 1995 | Fourth place | 118 pounds | John Carroll University | Lake Catholic High School |
| Jason | Jones | 1995 | Fourth place | 158 pounds | Mount Union College | Claymont High School |
| Marcus | Lambdin | 1995 | Fourth place | 177 pounds | Mount Union College | Black River High School |
| Aaron | Sheets | 1995 | Fourth place | 275 pounds | John Carroll University | Meigs High School |
| Jason | Weigand | 1995 | Fifth place | 275 pounds | Mount Union College | West Holmes High School |
| Dale | Vernon | 1995 | Sixth place | 167 pounds | Heidelberg University | N/A High School (N/A) |
| Dan | Ambroziak | 1995 | Seventh place | 134 pounds | Mount Union College | Lake Catholic High School |
| Rick | Mokros | 1995 | Eighth place | 150 pounds | Ohio Northern University | Shadyside High School |
| Chris | Ricklic | 1994 | Champion | 167 pounds | Case Western Reserve University | New Philadelphia High School |
| Kelly | Keenan | 1994 | Second place | 177 pounds | Baldwin-Wallace College | Steubenville High School |
| Chris | Connelly | 1994 | Third place | 158 pounds | John Carroll University | Rocky River High School |
| Tom | Jackson | 1994 | Third place | 190 pounds | Heidelberg University | Rossford High School |
| Dan | Ambroziak | 1994 | Fourth place | 126 pounds | Mount Union College | Lake Catholic High School |
| Dave | Ciacci | 1994 | Fourth place | 134 pounds | Case Western Reserve University | Shenandoah High School |
| Jason | Weigand | 1994 | Fourth place | 275 pounds | Mount Union College | West Holmes High School |
| Matt | Colucci | 1994 | Sixth place | 126 pounds | John Carroll University | North High School (Delaware County) |
| Brian | Malloy | 1994 | Sixth place | 142 pounds | Mount Union College | Lake Catholic High School |
| Joey | Roby | 1994 | Sixth place | 167 pounds | Ohio Northern University | N/A High School (N/A) |
| Sean | Pellerite | 1994 | Sixth place | 190 pounds | John Carroll University | Olmsted Falls High School |
| J.R. | Richner | 1994 | Seventh place | 118 pounds | Mount Union College | Riverside High School (Lake County) |
| Doug | Knight | 1994 | Seventh place | 134 pounds | Baldwin-Wallace College | Steubenville High School |
| Dave | Wellmeier | 1994 | Seventh place | 158 pounds | Ohio Northern University | Central Catholic High School (Allen County) |
| Rick | Mokros | 1994 | Eighth place | 150 pounds | Ohio Northern University | Shadyside High School |
| Mike | Gillmor | 1993 | Third place | 150 pounds | John Carroll University | Nordonia High School |
| Walt | Karrenbauer | 1993 | Sixth place | 126 pounds | John Carroll University | Washington High School |
| Chris | Connelly | 1993 | Seventh place | 158 pounds | John Carroll University | Rocky River High School |
| Dale | Kaprosey | 1993 | Eighth place | 167 pounds | John Carroll University | Lake Catholic High School |
| Matt | Randolph | 1993 | Eighth place | 275 pounds | Heidelberg University | Wadsworth High School |
| Mike | Gillmor | 1992 | Champion | 142 pounds | John Carroll University | Nordonia High School |
| Dan | Bobish | 1992 | Champion | 275 pounds | Mount Union College | Maple Heights High School |
| Judd | Smith | 1992 | Fifth place | 177 pounds | John Carroll University | Cuyahoga Heights High School |
| Walt | Karrenbauer | 1992 | Sixth place | 126 pounds | John Carroll University | Washington High School |
| Tom | Jackson | 1992 | Sixth place | 190 pounds | Heidelberg University | Rossford High School |
| Dale | Kaprosey | 1992 | Seventh place | 167 pounds | John Carroll University | Lake Catholic High School |
| David | Buckiso | 1992 | Eighth place | 134 pounds | John Carroll University | Thomas Jefferson High School (N/A, Pennsylvania) |
| Dan | Hulten | 1992 | Eighth place | 158 pounds | Baldwin-Wallace College | Mentor High School |
| Judd | Smith | 1991 | Third place | 167 pounds | John Carroll University | Cuyahoga Heights High School |
| Sandy | Womack | 1991 | Fourth place | 150 pounds | Mount Union College | Buchtel High School |
| Dan | Bobish | 1991 | Fourth place | 275 pounds | Mount Union College | Maple Heights High School |
| John | Topoly | 1991 | Fifth place | 126 pounds | Mount Union College | Lake Catholic High School |
| Matt | Randolph | 1991 | Eighth place | 275 pounds | Heidelberg University | Wadsworth High School |
| David | Buckiso | 1990 | Second place | 134 pounds | John Carroll University | Thomas Jefferson High School (N/A, Pennsylvania) |
| Sandy | Womack | 1990 | Third place | 150 pounds | Mount Union College | Buchtel High School |
| Joe | Schmidt | 1990 | Third place | 177 pounds | John Carroll University | North Royalton High School |
| John | Topoly | 1990 | Fifth place | 126 pounds | Mount Union College | Lake Catholic High School |
| Corey | Bowser | 1990 | Seventh place | 190 pounds | John Carroll University | Carlisle High School |
| Kevin | Higgins | 1989 | Champion | 177 pounds | Baldwin-Wallace College | Elyria High School |
| Vince | Cameron | 1989 | Champion | 275 pounds | Ohio Northern University | Brookville High School |
| Pete | Hayek | 1989 | Second place | 126 pounds | John Carroll University | Lake Catholic High School |
| Joe | Schmidt | 1989 | Second place | 167 pounds | John Carroll University | North Royalton High School |
| Wendel | Donathan | 1989 | Third place | 134 pounds | Wittenberg University | Western Brown High School |
| Mike | Collica | 1989 | Third place | 142 pounds | John Carroll University | Twinsburg High School |
| Scott | Miller | 1989 | Fifth place | 158 pounds | Case Western Reserve University | N/A High School (N/A) |
| Carl | DeBernardo | 1989 | Fifth place | 177 pounds | John Carroll University | Christopher Columbus High School (N/A, Florida) |
| Todd | Hibbs | 1989 | Sixth place | 142 pounds | Mount Union College | Jefferson Union High School |
| Greg | Hanchin | 1989 | Sixth place | 177 pounds | Case Western Reserve University | N/A High School (N/A) |
| Scott | Brown | 1989 | Eighth place | 167 pounds | Mount Union College | Perry High School (Stark County) |
| Mark | Hoppel | 1988 | Champion | 167 pounds | Muskingum University | N/A High School (N/A) |
| Joe | Schmidt | 1988 | Second place | 167 pounds | John Carroll University | North Royalton High School |
| Scott | Miller | 1988 | Fifth place | 150 pounds | Case Western Reserve University | N/A High School (N/A) |
| Steve | Lacher | 1988 | Fifth place | 275 pounds | Mount Union College | Minerva High School |
| Brad | Rogers | 1988 | Sixth place | 126 pounds | Ohio Northern University | Sidney High School |
| Stan | Rhodes | 1988 | Eighth place | 126 pounds | John Carroll University | Cuyahoga Falls High School |
| Scott | Kaye | 1988 | Eighth place | 134 pounds | Ohio Northern University | N/A High School (N/A) |
| Darren | Scott | 1987 | Champion | 134 pounds | Ohio Northern University | Elida High School |
| Mark | Sullivan | 1987 | Second place | 275 pounds | John Carroll University | Lake Catholic High School |
| Pete | Hayek | 1987 | Fourth place | 126 pounds | John Carroll University | Lake Catholic High School |
| Jason | Barnett | 1987 | Fourth place | 167 pounds | John Carroll University | John-Baptiste de La Salle High School |
| Tom | Bennet | 1987 | Sixth place | 150 pounds | John Carroll University | Nelson Snider High School (N/A, Indiana) |
| Jay | Hines | 1987 | Seventh place | 167 pounds | Mount Union College | Lake High School (Stark County) |
| Todd | Hibbs | 1987 | Eighth place | 142 pounds | Mount Union College | Jefferson Union High School |
| John | Verdes | 1987 | Eighth place | 150 pounds | Heidelberg University | N/A High School (N/A) |
| Sam | Walker | 1986 | Second place | 177 pounds | John Carroll University | Nelson Snider High School (N/A, Indiana) |
| Randy | Simpson | 1986 | Third place | 126 pounds | Capital University | Union High School |
| Pete | Hayek | 1986 | Fourth place | 126 pounds | John Carroll University | Lake Catholic High School |
| Darren | Scott | 1986 | Fifth place | 134 pounds | Ohio Northern University | Elida High School |
| Daryl | Stumph | 1986 | Fifth place | 150 pounds | Hiram College | Valley Forge High School |
| Jason | Barnett | 1986 | Sixth place | 158 pounds | John Carroll University | John-Baptiste de La Salle High School |
| Greg | Finnan | 1986 | Sixth place | 190 pounds | John Carroll University | Saint Ignatius High School |
| Tony | DeCarlo | 1986 | Seventh place | 167 pounds | John Carroll University | Saint Joseph High School |
| Jay | Hines | 1986 | Eighth place | 167 pounds | Mount Union College | Lake High School (Stark County) |
| Tony | Auletta | 1985 | Third place | 118 pounds | John Carroll University | Mayfield High School |
| Tom | Bennet | 1985 | Third place | 142 pounds | John Carroll University | Nelson Snider High School (N/A, Indiana) |
| Daryl | Stumph | 1985 | Third place | 150 pounds | Hiram College | Valley Forge High School |
| Sam | Walker | 1985 | Fourth place | 177 pounds | John Carroll University | Nelson Snider High School (N/A, Indiana) |
| Sal | D'Angelo | 1985 | Fourth place | Heavyweight | John Carroll University | Lake Catholic High School |
| Randy | Cook | 1985 | Sixth place | 118 pounds | Mount Union College | Mentor High School |
| Jerry | Tennant | 1985 | Seventh place | 134 pounds | Mount Union College | Southeast High School (Portage County) |
| Jeff | Bryner | 1985 | Seventh place | 167 pounds | Ohio Northern University | Hilliard High School |
| Mike | Sessor | 1985 | Eighth place | 126 pounds | Mount Union College | Fairless High School |
| Jason | Barnett | 1985 | Eighth place | 150 pounds | John Carroll University | John-Baptiste de La Salle High School |
| Kevin | Troche | 1985 | Eighth place | 158 pounds | Hiram College | N/A High School (N/A) |
| Marty | Joseph | 1984 | Second place | 142 pounds | John Carroll University | Norton High School |
| Mark | Sullivan | 1984 | Second place | Heavyweight | John Carroll University | Lake Catholic High School |
| Nick | D'Angelo | 1984 | Second place | 190 pounds | John Carroll University | Lake Catholic High School |
| Daryl | Stumph | 1984 | Fourth place | 150 pounds | Hiram College | Valley Forge High School |
| Mike | Baker | 1984 | Fourth place | Heavyweight | Ohio Northern University | N/A High School (N/A) |
| Ed | Trizzino | 1984 | Sixth place | 150 pounds | Mount Union College | Saint Peter L. M. Chanel High School |
| Bill | McHugh | 1984 | Seventh place | 134 pounds | Ohio Northern University | N/A High School (N/A) |
| Tom | Diamond | 1984 | Seventh place | 158 pounds | Mount Union College | Saint Edward High School |
| Nick | D'Angelo | 1983 | Champion | 190 pounds | John Carroll University | Lake Catholic High School |
| Ed | Trizzino | 1983 | Fifth place | 150 pounds | Mount Union College | Saint Peter L. M. Chanel High School |
| Perry | Graehling | 1983 | Sixth place | 142 pounds | Hiram College | N/A High School (N/A) |
| Jim | Kerr | 1983 | Seventh place | 126 pounds | Baldwin-Wallace College | John Marshall High School |
| Marty | Joseph | 1983 | Eighth place | 142 pounds | John Carroll University | Norton High School |
| Steve | Hartder | 1983 | Eighth place | Heavyweight | Mount Union College | N/A High School (N/A) |
| Randy | Viviani | 1982 | Champion | 142 pounds | John Carroll University | Lake Catholic High School |
| Sal | D'Angelo | 1982 | Third place | Heavyweight | John Carroll University | Lake Catholic High School |
| Nick | D'Angelo | 1982 | Third place | 190 pounds | John Carroll University | Lake Catholic High School |
| Mark | Schell | 1982 | Sixth place | 177 pounds | John Carroll University | Bishop Michael J. Ready High School |
| Brett | Wyss | 1982 | Seventh place | 134 pounds | Hiram College | N/A High School (N/A) |
| Randall | Fee | 1982 | Eighth place | 118 pounds | Capital University | Groveport-Madison High School |
| Clark | Brunbaugh | 1982 | Eighth place | 150 pounds | Case Western Reserve University | Tallmadge High School |
| Dan | Stefancin | 1981 | Champion | 118 pounds | John Carroll University | Saint Ignatius High School |
| Chad | Gross | 1981 | Champion | 134 pounds | John Carroll University | Valley Forge High School |
| Brett | Wyss | 1981 | Third place | 142 pounds | Hiram College | N/A High School (N/A) |
| Tom | Gallagher | 1981 | Fifth place | 150 pounds | John Carroll University | Mayfield High School |
| Dennis | Hareza | 1981 | Fifth place | 167 pounds | John Carroll University | Chartiers Valley High School (N/A, Pennsylvania) |
| Doug | Jewett | 1981 | Sixth place | 158 pounds | Muskingum University | Tri-Valley High School |
| Randy | Viviani | 1981 | Seventh place | 142 pounds | John Carroll University | Lake Catholic High School |
| Kirk | Benson | 1981 | Seventh place | 150 pounds | Muskingum University | N/A High School (N/A) |
| Paul | Cotton | 1981 | Eighth place | 118 pounds | Mount Union College | Marlington High School |
| Michael | Houska | 1981 | Eighth place | 167 pounds | Hiram College | N/A High School (N/A) |
| Alan | Logan | 1981 | Eighth place | 190 pounds | Muskingum University | Barnesville High School |
| Steve | Batanian | 1980 | Fourth place | 126 pounds | John Carroll University | Edgewood High School (Ashtabula County) |
| Charles | Catanzarite | 1980 | Fourth place | 158 pounds | John Carroll University | Wooster High School |
| Dan | Browning | 1980 | Fifth place | 134 pounds | Hiram College | Southeast High School (Portage County) |
| Joe | Roth | 1980 | Sixth place | 190 pounds | John Carroll University | Hickory High School (Hickory, Pennsylvania) |
| Larry | Grimes | 1980 | Seventh place | Heavyweight | Muskingum University | N/A High School (N/A) |
| Jeff | Freedman | 1979 | Champion | 158 pounds | Ashland University | N/A High School (N/A) |
| John | Ciotoli | 1979 | Third place | 134 pounds | Cleveland State University | N/A High School (N/A) |
| Paul | Petrella | 1979 | Third place | 177 pounds | Baldwin-Wallace College | Mansfield High School |
| Mike | Trautman | 1979 | Fourth place | 190 pounds | John Carroll University | Saint Mary Central Catholic High School |
| Mark | Johnson | 1979 | Fifth place | 167 pounds | Baldwin-Wallace College | N/A High School (N/A) |
| Dan | Stefancin | 1979 | Seventh place | 118 pounds | John Carroll University | Saint Ignatius High School |
| Mike | Arnold | 1979 | Seventh place | 126 pounds | Ashland University | N/A High School (N/A) |
| Mark | Hettinger | 1979 | Seventh place | 134 pounds | Ashland University | Aurora High School |
| Don | Mason | 1979 | Seventh place | 158 pounds | Muskingum University | N/A High School (N/A) |
| George | Werling | 1979 | Eighth place | 118 pounds | Ashland University | N/A High School (N/A) |
| Mario | Alemagno | 1979 | Eighth place | 177 pounds | John Carroll University | James A. Hawken High School |
| Joel | Chenevy | 1979 | Eighth place | Heavyweight | Ashland University | Jackson High School (Stark County) |
| Jim | Weir | 1978 | Champion | 167 pounds | John Carroll University | Cleveland Heights-University Heights High School |
| Paul | Petrella | 1978 | Champion | 177 pounds | Baldwin-Wallace College | Mansfield High School |
| Ken | Berry | 1978 | Second place | 167 pounds | Hiram College | N/A High School (N/A) |
| Ken | Wilcox | 1978 | Second place | Heavyweight | Mount Union College | N/A High School (N/A) |
| Alain | Arnold | 1978 | Fourth place | 126 pounds | Ashland University | N/A High School (N/A) |
| Doug | Burton | 1978 | Fourth place | 150 pounds | Ohio Northern University | N/A High School (N/A) |
| Stephen | Hohl | 1978 | Fifth place | 142 pounds | Ohio Northern University | N/A High School (N/A) |
| Kevin | Brandenburg | 1978 | Fifth place | 150 pounds | Hiram College | N/A High School (N/A) |
| Jim | Weir | 1977 | Champion | 167 pounds | John Carroll University | Cleveland Heights-University Heights High School |
| Brad | Bowman | 1977 | Second place | 177 pounds | John Carroll University | Warrensville Heights High School |
| Jeff | Freedman | 1977 | Third place | 158 pounds | Ashland University | N/A High School (N/A) |
| Bill | Kahl | 1977 | Third place | Heavyweight | John Carroll University | Euclid High School |
| Keith | Fabrizzi | 1977 | Sixth place | 118 pounds | Hiram College | N/A High School (N/A) |
| Mike | Arnold | 1977 | Sixth place | 126 pounds | Ashland University | N/A High School (N/A) |
| Kevin | Brandenburg | 1977 | Sixth place | 150 pounds | Hiram College | N/A High School (N/A) |
| Jack | Mulhall | 1976 | Champion | 118 pounds | John Carroll University | Saint Joseph High School |
| Mark | Hawald I | 1976 | Champion | 134 pounds | John Carroll University | Beachwood High School |
| Jim | Weir | 1976 | Champion | 158 pounds | John Carroll University | Cleveland Heights-University Heights High School |
| Clayton | Barnard | 1976 | Second place | 167 pounds | Ashland University | N/A High School (N/A) |
| Brad | Bowman | 1976 | Second place | 177 pounds | John Carroll University | Warrensville Heights High School |
| Ken | Meditz | 1976 | Third place | 167 pounds | John Carroll University | Saint Joseph High School |
| Ed | Hissa | 1976 | Third place | 190 pounds | Ashland University | N/A High School (N/A) |
| Alex | Massiello | 1976 | Fourth place | 142 pounds | Hiram College | N/A High School (N/A) |
| Doug | Burton | 1976 | Fifth place | 150 pounds | Ohio Northern University | N/A High School (N/A) |
| Skip | Fair | 1976 | Fifth place | 177 pounds | Ashland University | Valley Forge High School |
| Kevin | Hinkel | 1976 | Fifth place | 190 pounds | John Carroll University | Saint Ignatius High School |
| Al | Evangelista | 1976 | Sixth place | 126 pounds | John Carroll University | Richmond Heights High School |
| Joe | Collins | 1976 | Sixth place | Heavyweight | Ashland University | Mapleton High School |
| Mark | Hawald I | 1975 | Champion | 134 pounds | John Carroll University | Beachwood High School |
| Charles | Becks | 1975 | Champion | 150 pounds | John Carroll University | Thomas W. Harvey High School |
| Brad | Bowman | 1975 | Champion | 177 pounds | John Carroll University | Warrensville Heights High School |
| Joe | Bertolone | 1975 | Champion | Heavyweight | John Carroll University | Warrensville Heights High School |
| Jack | Mulhall | 1975 | Second place | 118 pounds | John Carroll University | Saint Joseph High School |
| Skip | Fair | 1975 | Second place | 190 pounds | Ashland University | Valley Forge High School |
| Clayton | Barnard | 1975 | Third place | 167 pounds | Ashland University | N/A High School (N/A) |
| Raleigh | Clemons | 1975 | Fourth place | 158 pounds | Ashland University | N/A High School (N/A) |
| Jim | Friedrich | 1975 | Fifth place | 150 pounds | Oberlin College | N/A High School (N/A) |
| James | Aquilo | 1975 | Sixth place | 118 pounds | Mount Union College | Marlington High School |
| Rae | McDonald | 1975 | Sixth place | 134 pounds | Mount Union College | Timken High School |
| Joe | Bertolone | 1974 | Champion | Heavyweight | John Carroll University | Warrensville Heights High School |
| Al | Evangelista | 1974 | Second place | 126 pounds | John Carroll University | Richmond Heights High School |
| Rae | McDonald | 1974 | Second place | 134 pounds | Mount Union College | Timken High School |
| Charles | Becks | 1974 | Second place | 150 pounds | John Carroll University | Thomas W. Harvey High School |
| Mark | Hawald I | 1974 | Third place | 134 pounds | John Carroll University | Beachwood High School |
| Tim | Pazyniak | 1974 | Third place | 142 pounds | John Carroll University | Charles F. Brush High School |
| Elijah | Whitten | 1974 | Third place | 177 pounds | Ashland University | N/A High School (N/A) |
| Rich | Tschantz | 1974 | Fourth place | 150 pounds | Mount Union College | Carrollton High School |
| Clayton | Barnard | 1974 | Fourth place | 158 pounds | Ashland University | N/A High School (N/A) |
| Ron | Angello | 1974 | Fifth place | 118 pounds | Ashland University | Garfield Heights High School |
| Greg | Low | 1974 | Fifth place | Heavyweight | Ashland University | N/A High School (N/A) |
| Tom | Corbo | 1974 | Sixth place | 177 pounds | John Carroll University | Charles F. Brush High School |