| Four-time NCAA Division 3 Wrestling All-Americans | ||||||
| Data updated after the 2013 NCAA Division 3 Wrestling Championships | ||||||
| Data compiled by Dan Cosimi of The Ohio Wrestling Network | ||||||
| Total: 3 Four-time All-Americans, 12 All-America honors | ||||||
| First | Last | Year | Place | Weight | College | High School |
| Zak | Kallai | 2004 | Eighth place | 149 pounds | Case Western Reserve University | Wadsworth High School |
| Zak | Kallai | 2003 | Eighth place | 149 pounds | Case Western Reserve University | Wadsworth High School |
| Zak | Kallai | 2002 | Fifth place | 149 pounds | Case Western Reserve University | Wadsworth High School |
| Zak | Kallai | 2001 | Sixth place | 149 pounds | Case Western Reserve University | Wadsworth High School |
| Kyle | Kwiat | 2013 | Champion | 174 pounds | Ohio Northern University | Cecilius Calvert High School |
| Kyle | Kwiat | 2012 | Champion | 174 pounds | Ohio Northern University | Cecilius Calvert High School |
| Kyle | Kwiat | 2011 | Fifth place | 174 pounds | Ohio Northern University | Cecilius Calvert High School |
| Kyle | Kwiat | 2010 | Fourth place | 174 pounds | Ohio Northern University | Cecilius Calvert High School |
| Jimmy | Wallace | 2002 | Champion | 157 pounds | Wilmington College | Valley View High School |
| Jimmy | Wallace | 2001 | Third place | 157 pounds | Wilmington College | Valley View High School |
| Jimmy | Wallace | 2000 | Fifth place | 149 pounds | Wilmington College | Valley View High School |
| Jimmy | Wallace | 1999 | Fifth place | 149 pounds | Wilmington College | Valley View High School |