| Three-time NCAA Division 3 Wrestling All-Americans | ||||||
| Data updated after the 2013 NCAA Division 3 Wrestling Championships | ||||||
| Data compiled by Dan Cosimi of The Ohio Wrestling Network | ||||||
| Total: 24 Three-time All-Americans, 75 All-America honors | ||||||
| Active: 0 | ||||||
| First | Last | Year | Place | Weight | College | High School |
| Dan | Ambroziak | 1997 | Fifth place | 142 pounds | Mount Union College | Lake Catholic High School |
| Dan | Ambroziak | 1995 | Seventh place | 134 pounds | Mount Union College | Lake Catholic High School |
| Dan | Ambroziak | 1994 | Fourth place | 126 pounds | Mount Union College | Lake Catholic High School |
| Clayton | Barnard | 1976 | Second place | 167 pounds | Ashland University | N/A High School (N/A) |
| Clayton | Barnard | 1975 | Third place | 167 pounds | Ashland University | N/A High School (N/A) |
| Clayton | Barnard | 1974 | Fourth place | 158 pounds | Ashland University | N/A High School (N/A) |
| Jason | Barnett | 1987 | Fourth place | 167 pounds | John Carroll University | John-Baptiste de La Salle High School |
| Jason | Barnett | 1986 | Sixth place | 158 pounds | John Carroll University | John-Baptiste de La Salle High School |
| Jason | Barnett | 1985 | Eighth place | 150 pounds | John Carroll University | John-Baptiste de La Salle High School |
| Brad | Bowman | 1977 | Second place | 177 pounds | John Carroll University | Warrensville Heights High School |
| Brad | Bowman | 1976 | Second place | 177 pounds | John Carroll University | Warrensville Heights High School |
| Brad | Bowman | 1975 | Champion | 177 pounds | John Carroll University | Warrensville Heights High School |
| Nick | D'Angelo | 1984 | Second place | 190 pounds | John Carroll University | Lake Catholic High School |
| Nick | D'Angelo | 1983 | Champion | 190 pounds | John Carroll University | Lake Catholic High School |
| Nick | D'Angelo | 1982 | Third place | 190 pounds | John Carroll University | Lake Catholic High School |
| Isaac | Dukes | 2012 | Seventh place | 157 pounds | Case Western Reserve University | Ravenna High School |
| Isaac | Dukes | 2011 | Third place | 149 pounds | Case Western Reserve University | Ravenna High School |
| Isaac | Dukes | 2010 | Champion | 149 pounds | Case Western Reserve University | Ravenna High School |
| Matt | Hamill | 1998 | Champion | 190 pounds | Rochester Institute of Technology | Loveland High School |
| Matt | Hamill | 1997 | Champion | 167 pounds | Rochester Institute of Technology | Loveland High School |
| Matt | Hamill | 1999 | Champion | 197 pounds | Rochester Institute of Technology | Loveland High School |
| Mark | Hawald I | 1976 | Champion | 134 pounds | John Carroll University | Beachwood High School |
| Mark | Hawald I | 1975 | Champion | 134 pounds | John Carroll University | Beachwood High School |
| Mark | Hawald I | 1974 | Third place | 134 pounds | John Carroll University | Beachwood High School |
| Pete | Hayek | 1989 | Second place | 126 pounds | John Carroll University | Lake Catholic High School |
| Pete | Hayek | 1987 | Fourth place | 126 pounds | John Carroll University | Lake Catholic High School |
| Pete | Hayek | 1986 | Fourth place | 126 pounds | John Carroll University | Lake Catholic High School |
| Zak | Kallai | 2004 | Eighth place | 149 pounds | Case Western Reserve University | Wadsworth High School |
| Zak | Kallai | 2003 | Eighth place | 149 pounds | Case Western Reserve University | Wadsworth High School |
| Zak | Kallai | 2002 | Fifth place | 149 pounds | Case Western Reserve University | Wadsworth High School |
| Zak | Kallai | 2001 | Sixth place | 149 pounds | Case Western Reserve University | Wadsworth High School |
| Justin | Kerr | 1999 | Eighth place | 197 pounds | John Carroll University | Mapleton High School |
| Justin | Kerr | 1998 | Third place | 167 pounds | John Carroll University | Mapleton High School |
| Justin | Kerr | 1997 | Sixth place | 167 pounds | John Carroll University | Mapleton High School |
| Kyle | Kwiat | 2013 | Champion | 174 pounds | Ohio Northern University | Cecilius Calvert High School |
| Kyle | Kwiat | 2012 | Champion | 174 pounds | Ohio Northern University | Cecilius Calvert High School |
| Kyle | Kwiat | 2011 | Fifth place | 174 pounds | Ohio Northern University | Cecilius Calvert High School |
| Kyle | Kwiat | 2010 | Fourth place | 174 pounds | Ohio Northern University | Cecilius Calvert High School |
| Joe | Maiani | 1998 | Second place | 150 pounds | Ohio Northern University | Saint Mary Central Catholic High School |
| Joe | Maiani | 1997 | Sixth place | 150 pounds | Ohio Northern University | Saint Mary Central Catholic High School |
| Joe | Maiani | 1996 | Eighth place | 142 pounds | Ohio Northern University | Saint Mary Central Catholic High School |
| Luke | Miller | 2011 | Third place | 165 pounds | Ohio Northern University | Indiana High School (Indiana, Pennsylvania) |
| Luke | Miller | 2010 | Champion | 157 pounds | Ohio Northern University | Indiana High School (Indiana, Pennsylvania) |
| Luke | Miller | 2009 | Fourth place | 157 pounds | Ohio Northern University | Indiana High School (Indiana, Pennsylvania) |
| Jason | Roush | 2007 | Second place | 149 pounds | College of Mount Saint Joseph | Van Wert High School |
| Jason | Roush | 2006 | Third place | 149 pounds | College of Mount Saint Joseph | Van Wert High School |
| Jason | Roush | 2005 | Third place | 149 pounds | College of Mount Saint Joseph | Van Wert High School |
| Bill | Schindel | 2011 | Third place | 197 pounds | University of Mount Union | Archbishop Edward F. Hoban High School |
| Bill | Schindel | 2010 | Seventh place | 197 pounds | Mount Union College | Archbishop Edward F. Hoban High School |
| Bill | Schindel | 2009 | Eighth place | 197 pounds | Mount Union College | Archbishop Edward F. Hoban High School |
| Joe | Schmidt | 1990 | Third place | 177 pounds | John Carroll University | North Royalton High School |
| Joe | Schmidt | 1989 | Second place | 167 pounds | John Carroll University | North Royalton High School |
| Joe | Schmidt | 1988 | Second place | 167 pounds | John Carroll University | North Royalton High School |
| Elliott | Spence | 2008 | Second place | 149 pounds | College of Mount Saint Joseph | Archbishop William H. Elder High School |
| Elliott | Spence | 2007 | Eighth place | 157 pounds | College of Mount Saint Joseph | Archbishop William H. Elder High School |
| Elliott | Spence | 2006 | Eighth place | 157 pounds | College of Mount Saint Joseph | Archbishop William H. Elder High School |
| Daryl | Stumph | 1986 | Fifth place | 150 pounds | Hiram College | Valley Forge High School |
| Daryl | Stumph | 1985 | Third place | 150 pounds | Hiram College | Valley Forge High School |
| Daryl | Stumph | 1984 | Fourth place | 150 pounds | Hiram College | Valley Forge High School |
| Eric | Urdzik | 2002 | Second place | 285 pounds | John Carroll University | Brecksville-Broadview Heights High School |
| Eric | Urdzik | 2001 | Fifth place | 285 pounds | John Carroll University | Brecksville-Broadview Heights High School |
| Eric | Urdzik | 2000 | Seventh place | 285 pounds | John Carroll University | Brecksville-Broadview Heights High School |
| Andrew | Vogel | 2003 | Seventh place | 149 pounds | Messiah College | Cuyahoga Valley Christian Academy |
| Andrew | Vogel | 2002 | Seventh place | 149 pounds | Messiah College | Cuyahoga Valley Christian Academy |
| Andrew | Vogel | 2001 | Second place | 149 pounds | Messiah College | Cuyahoga Valley Christian Academy |
| Jimmy | Wallace | 2002 | Champion | 157 pounds | Wilmington College | Valley View High School |
| Jimmy | Wallace | 2001 | Third place | 157 pounds | Wilmington College | Valley View High School |
| Jimmy | Wallace | 2000 | Fifth place | 149 pounds | Wilmington College | Valley View High School |
| Jimmy | Wallace | 1999 | Fifth place | 149 pounds | Wilmington College | Valley View High School |
| Jason | Weigand | 1996 | Eighth place | 275 pounds | Mount Union College | West Holmes High School |
| Jason | Weigand | 1995 | Fifth place | 275 pounds | Mount Union College | West Holmes High School |
| Jason | Weigand | 1994 | Fourth place | 275 pounds | Mount Union College | West Holmes High School |
| Jim | Weir | 1978 | Champion | 167 pounds | John Carroll University | Cleveland Heights-University Heights High School |
| Jim | Weir | 1977 | Champion | 167 pounds | John Carroll University | Cleveland Heights-University Heights High School |
| Jim | Weir | 1976 | Champion | 158 pounds | John Carroll University | Cleveland Heights-University Heights High School |