| Two-time NCWA Wrestling All-Americans | ||||||
| Data updated after the 2013 NCWA Wrestling Championships | ||||||
| Data compiled by Dan Cosimi of The Ohio Wrestling Network | ||||||
| Total: 5 Two-time All-Americans, 11 All-America honors | ||||||
| Active: 2 (Royal Brettrager II and Ian Jones) | ||||||
| First | Last | Year | Place | Weight | College | High School |
| Dan | Brower | 2009 | Second place | 197 pounds | Miami University | Bellbrook High School |
| Dan | Brower | 2008 | Fifth place | 197 pounds | Miami University | Bellbrook High School |
| Royal | Brettrager II | 2013 | Third place | 184 pounds | Liberty University | Kirtland High School |
| Royal | Brettrager II | 2012 | Second place | 184 pounds | Liberty University | Kirtland High School |
| Lance | Esch | 2008 | Fifth place | 174 pounds | University of the Rio Grande | Indian Lake High School |
| Lance | Esch | 2007 | Second place | 165 pounds | University of the Rio Grande | Indian Lake High School |
| Ian | Jones | 2013 | Third place | 285 pounds | The Apprentice School | Thomas W. Harvey High School |
| Ian | Jones | 2012 | Eighth place | 285 pounds | The Apprentice School | Thomas W. Harvey High School |
| Adam | Murray | 2008 | Champion | 197 pounds | University of Toledo | North High School (Fairfield County) |
| Adam | Murray | 2007 | Champion | 197 pounds | University of Toledo | North High School (Fairfield County) |
| Adam | Murray | 2006 | Champion | 197 pounds | University of Toledo | North High School (Fairfield County) |