| Two-time NJCAA Wrestling All-Americans | ||||||
| Data updated after the 2013 NJCAA Wrestling Championships | ||||||
| Data compiled by Dan Cosimi of The Ohio Wrestling Network | ||||||
| Total: 6 Two-time All-Americans, 12 All-America honors | ||||||
| Active: 0 | ||||||
| First | Last | Year | Place | Weight | College | High School |
| Greg | Byrne | 1979 | Champion | Heavyweight | Lakeland Community College | Saint Joseph High School |
| Greg | Byrne | 1978 | Champion | Heavyweight | Lakeland Community College | Saint Joseph High School |
| Bill | Karpowicz | 1976 | Champion | 134 pounds | Cuyahoga Community College | John Marshall High School |
| Bill | Karpowicz | 1975 | Champion | 134 pounds | Cuyahoga Community College | John Marshall High School |
| Antione | Love | 2006 | Third place | 174 pounds | Iowa Central Community College | Lincoln High School |
| Antione | Love | 2005 | Sixth place | 174 pounds | Iowa Central Community College | Lincoln High School |
| John | McGhee | 1999 | Sixth place | 174 pounds | Iowa Central Community College | Coventry High School |
| John | McGhee | 1998 | Champion | 158 pounds | Iowa Central Community College | Coventry High School |
| Mike | Ryba | 1982 | Champion | 118 pounds | Cuyahoga Community College | Nordonia High School |
| Mike | Ryba | 1981 | Champion | 118 pounds | Cuyahoga Community College | Nordonia High School |
| John | Zele | 1980 | Champion | 177 pounds | Lakeland Community College | Saint Joseph High School |
| John | Zele | 1979 | Champion | 177 pounds | Lakeland Community College | Saint Joseph High School |